$ 35.00 $ 40.00
Stir up this delicate, lemon cake finished with a sprinkle of Milford Spice Company's Sweet Tooth vanilla sugar for a sweet treat to share with friends and family this holiday season! Or gift this delicious set to the baker in your life!
This olive oil cake is super versatile, subtly sweet and delicate in flavor. Enjoy for breakfast, or at teatime with Greek yogurt and berries, or share with loved ones at a holiday dinner party with a mug of warm cider.
Bake up some holiday cheer this season!
Creede Olive Oil Co. Meyer Lemon Extra Virgin Olive Oil - 375 mL bottle
Creede Olive Oil Co. Olive Oil Cake Mix
Milford Spice Company Sweet Tooth - Vanilla Sugar
$ 10.00
Shopping for someone else but not sure what to give them? Give them the gift of choice with a Creede Olive Oil Co. Gift Card.
Gift cards are delivered by email and contain instructions to redeem them at checkout. Our gift cards have no additional processing fees.
$ 23.00 $ 25.00
TWO great cookbooks for the price of one!! Both are in-house, all our own favorite recipes!!
BRAND NEW!! The Little Book of Balsamic Cocktails, featuring 22 cocktail and mocktail recipes using our delicious aged balsamics! Color photo of each drink!
AND our Creede Olive Oil Cookbook, featuring more than 90 recipes using olive oils and balsamics.
$ 5.00
Pure Pour fits inside and couples over a bottle. It is a leak-proof pour spout designed to stop waste. Others don't fit correctly and come apart easily. Pure Pour is low tech, inexpensive, won't rust and comes with a spout cover. Fits our 375 mL bottles.
$ 15.00
A companion guide to our wonderful products!
Makes a great gift for the food lover in your life!
90 recipes featuring Creede Olive Oil products!
Drinks
Appetizers
Salads
Pasta
Breakfast
Game
Beef
Pork
Chicken
Seafood
Vegetables
Desserts
$ 60.00
Build your the perfect unique gift basket with the help of a personal in-store shopper.
Please call (719-658-2443) or come by the store Monday through Saturday from 11:00 to 4:00 to customize your basket!
Choose your own adventure, or try a selection we have made for you like Hot and Spicy Favorites, Cocktail Fixins, or Pasta Night!
Choose your basket type and shape, the contents, and we will wrap it up and make it pretty with a bow!
Cost will vary with addition of taxes and shipping, but start at $60, $80, and $100.
(Did you know that out of state customers pay no sales tax?!)
$ 45.00 $ 47.50
This special gift duo includes two full size 375mL bottles - one each of our traditional 18 year aged balsamic and one of our house blend extra virgin olive oil. Receive both at a discounted price with a free gift box with our custom Creede Olive Oil logo that fits both bottles, AND a printed recipe suggestion card for your duo!!
Our traditional 18 year aged balsamic vinegar from Modena, Italy is so smooth you could sip it after dinner. Use it as a drizzle on aged cheeses, cured meats and fresh fruit or as a dessert sauce for vanilla ice cream and strawberries. Makes a great marinade or a fabulous finish on your salmon.
Our house blend oil is a blend of three of our favorite Tunisian extra virgin olive oils. What more can you ask for when it comes to food? Huge flavor for use in bread dipping and a wonderful base for any salad dressing.
SPECIAL PRICE!!
$ 22.00 $ 25.00
This special gift duo includes two small 100mL bottles - one each of our traditional 18 year aged balsamic and one of our house blend extra virgin olive oil. Receive both at a discounted price with a free gift box with our custom Creede Olive Oil logo that fits both bottles, AND a printed recipe suggestion card for your duo!!
Our traditional 18 year aged balsamic vinegar from Modena, Italy is so smooth you could sip it after dinner. Use it as a drizzle on aged cheeses, cured meats and fresh fruit or as a dessert sauce for vanilla ice cream and strawberries. Makes a great marinade or a fabulous finish on your salmon.
Our house blend oil is a blend of three of our favorite Tunisian extra virgin olive oils. What more can you ask for when it comes to food? Huge flavor for use in bread dipping and a wonderful base for any salad dressing.
SPECIAL PRICE!!
$ 10.00
NEW! NEW! NEW!!
Our own in-house recipes for delicious cocktails and mocktails, all made with our luscious aged balsamics from Modena, Italy!
Written by owner Rebeca Liss and Leslie Grady
Soft cover, 50 pages, 22 recipes--each with a color photograph.
$10.00
Free
Try these conversions to extra virgin olive oil for a healthier change!
Free
Try some of these great pairings of our olive oils and balsamics for yourself!!
$ 3.00
Cardboard Gift Box printed with green Creede Olive Oil logo
Fits two sampler size (100mL) bottles of any oil or balsamic
BOX ONLY, NO CONTENTS
$ 3.50
Cardboard Gift Box printed with green Creede Olive Oil logo
Fits two full size (375mL) bottles of any oil or balsamic
BOX ONLY, NO CONTENTS
$ 3.50
Cardboard Gift Box printed with green Creede Olive Oil logo
Fits four sampler size (100mL) bottles of any oil or balsamic combination - create your own set!
BOX ONLY, NO CONTENTS
$ 4.50
Cardboard Gift Box printed with green Creede Olive Oil logo
Fits six sampler size (100mL) bottles of any oil or balsamic combination - create your own set!
BOX ONLY, NO CONTENTS
$ 11.00
Start your day with this mild smokey flavor over eggs. Great on salads, as extra flavor in your beans, and tasty for dipping bread.
$ 11.00
Fresh raw basil flavor year round! This distinctive basil oil is made from extra virgin olive oil infused with sweet basil flavor. It is perfect grilling and sauteing. Toss it with pasta and salads with balsamic vinegar. Drizzle it on tomatoes, steamed vegetables, fall soups, soft cheeses, or on a pizza pie before adding any other ingredients.
$ 11.00
Likely the first time you will try a truffle oil that truly presents the full truffle flavor. Use for salads, pastas, and embellish all kinds of meats and vegetables with it.
$ 11.00
This unique balsamic carries a great blueberry aroma, with a crisp and very tart flavor with a mild sweetness. It is great for dressing, dessert sauces or a marinade for your pork or other meat.
$ 11.00
If you can't live without butter, this flavor will help you enjoy the taste of butter and eat healthy. Use it on vegetables, pasta, salads and even popcorn.
$ 11.00
NEW!! Rich and decadent, our caramelized onion dark balsamic is a winner. Toss into cold pasta with chopped tomatoes, charcuterie and some Parmesan cheese for a delightful lunch. Use for roasting any vegetables, or a whole chicken. Plate some figs, burrata and pistachios, top with this balsamic and you have a beautiful snack.
A perfect pairing would be Caramelized Onion Dark Balsamic and our Rosemary EVOO.
$ 11.00
This hot, but delicious extra virgin olive oil has a nice forward flavor before the chili kicks in. Try in a stir fry dish, or on chicken, fish, veggies or rice. It is also terrific in sauces, soups and stews. Mix with our Mango Balsamic for a fantastic dressing.
$ 11.00
This balsamic is beyond amazing! Its delicious rich flavor can be drizzled on vanilla ice cream, cake, and a berry salad! Yet it's also terrific as a marinade on meat, vegetables, and salads.
$ 11.00
This Habanero extra virgin olive oil is our hottest option... rounded out with added citrus flavor of Blood Orange - similar to our Citrus Habanero Pure Olive Oil. It's not for the faint of heart! It starts with a nice sweet citrusy orange flavor and then it hits the back of your throat and heat kicks in. It's delicious when used as an oil to saute your veggies or in an Asian stir fry. Use in carnitas or even on pizza as a finishing oil. A spicy citrus sensation!
$ 11.00
Light and refreshing with sweet coconut flavor tempered with tart 12 year cask aged white balsamic. Use as a marinade for a healthy version of coconut shrimp or add to your favorite seltzer for the perfect summer drink.
$ 11.00
A refreshing combination of Cucumber and Lime, this white balsamic is delicious in cocktails. Also try as a dressing on a jicama salad or add in an Asian slaw with pistachios. Pair with any of our spicy olive oils for great salad dressing.
$ 11.00
This is one of our most unique products and it is surprisingly delicious. It's a great option for coleslaw. It also provides a great complement to any dish that uses spicy peppers (jalapeño poppers) - adding a sweet and acid component. Use as a condiment on a Cubano sandwich. Add some chopped jalapeño pepper and use as a condiment for a turkey burger. Or try in your favorite potato salad dish. Try pairing this with Meyer Lemon EVOO.
$ 11.00
This balsamic vinegar from Modena, Italy is so smooth you could sip it after dinner. Use it as a drizzle on aged cheeses, cured meats and fresh fruit or as a dessert sauce for vanilla ice cream and strawberries. Makes a great marinade or a fabulous finish on your salmon.
$ 11.00
FRESH Raw Garlic flavor!! – (Not roasted)
This flavor is a little sharper and stronger with more garlic bite than our roasted garlic flavor. Will definitely keep the vampires at bay.
*Drizzle over halved brussels sprouts (or any vegetable) and roast in the oven
*Great for marinades
*Use in place of raw garlic in many recipes
$ 11.00
This smooth garlic balsamic will enhance any of your cooking. Sprinkle on your burgers for a nice kick, or use as part of a wonderful salad dressing. It is fantastic on seafood.
$ 11.00
One of our most popular olive oils, you can smell the Parmesan before you pour onto a bowl of pasta, with fresh grated cheese for texture, or over a fresh bead of tomatoes with fresh basil. Additionally wonderful spread over fresh bread before toasting in the oven!
$ 11.00
This is a blend of our favorite extra virgin olive oils.
$ 11.00
Now that's Italian! This wonderful Olive Oil can be used as a bread dipping oil, drizzled on pasta, rice, over pizza, or on a salad. Smother on chicken before roasting! Features the flavors of garlic, rosemary, basil and oregano.
$ 11.00
A delicious savory white balsamic flavored with the most popular Italian herbs... garlic, basil, rosemary and oregano. Use this one as a glaze for oven roasted portobello mushrooms or as a dressing for a juicy tomato and cucumber salad. Try it over grilled halibut with some lemon slices. Or toss into sautéed spinach. Pair with our Parmesan Cheese Rosemary EVOO for the ultimate Italian combination.
$ 11.00
The flavor of spicy jalapeños and garlic ending with a slight slow burn. Great drizzled on pizza or pasta. Add to sautéed veggies for a little kick. Try scrambling some eggs with this oil too!
$ 11.00
This 12 Year-Aged white balsamic has a terrific sweet and tart flavor with a little spicy kick from the jalapeno. Use it as a marinade on meats for fajitas or tacos. Mix it in with some homemade salsa, a taco salad or on fresh fruit.
$ 11.00
This zesty peppery olive oil will put a zing in your seafood dish. Sprinkle over fish before broiling, or add to a fresh scallop and shrimp salad. Wonderful over tomatoes with artichoke hearts, or even for dipping bread.
$ 11.00
This nice light white balsamic combines a smoky mesquite flavor with the heat of habanero. This is perfect to use when grilling white meat or seafood, or be adventurous and use it as a nice glaze for your grilled steaks. Add it to a fruit salsa for an accompaniment to Mexican barbecue or grilled vegetables.
$ 11.00
Meyer Lemon Olive Oil is a great olive oil to grill any seafood in and give it that crisp Meyer lemon flavor. Saute your veggies, shrimp, or scallops with it, or just sprinkle of your salad. It is a refreshing olive oil with a bright finish.
$ 11.00
A great flavor combination. Try on pasta, in a risotto or as a bread dipping oil.
$ 11.00
NEW!! A nice light version of our dark balsamic, you can use this flavor in so many ways. Combine with our Basil EVOO and a dollop of strawberry preserves to create a fruity yet tart salad dressing. Try drizzled into a salad with roasted walnuts and feta cheese. Or use a splash in club soda over ice for a refreshing treat, add rum or vodka if you like!
$ 11.00
$ 11.00
This Olive Oil is unfiltered and naturally settled. One word says it all, GARLIC! Great on steaks, potatoes, and pizza. Braise chicken with this oil and enjoy the wonderful flavors. Enhance the flavor of an artichoke salad with this terrific oil.
$ 11.00
Light rosemary flavor that is wonderful on salads. Use with many meats. Terrific on steamed vegetables, soups, and cheese. Wonderful over a tomato and cucumber salad.
$ 11.00
This balsamic adds a wonderful flavor to meats as a marinade or as a finishing touch. Add it to your grilled vegetables for a smokey flavor.
$ 11.00
NEW!! A tasty combination of chile powder with the addition of traditional molé spices (coffee, light cinnamon, nuts and chocolate) -- all flavors that compliment our balsamic so well! This is definitely our new favorite flavor.
Not “hot” spicy but “flavorful” spicy, this balsamic would be delicious as a stand-alone sauce for chicken, pork or beef. You could top your enchiladas, tacos, burritos or tostadas with it, or use to add flavor to Mexican or cauliflower rice. Try pairing with our Blood Orange or Roasted Garlic EVOO.
*This flavor has chile powder added to the balsamic vinegar so it is recommended to shake the bottles once in a while or a cap can form on the top of the product in the bottle.
$ 11.00
This wonderful white balsamic gives you the perfect blend of fresh strawberry and peach. Sweet yet tart. Excellent on coleslaw, or over a spinach salad with fresh srawberries and nuts. Also drizzle over fresh berries or melon.
$ 11.00
This Tradizionale Modena balsamic vinegar from Modena, Italy is so smooth you could sip it after dinner. Aged 18 years in oak casks. Use it as a drizzle on aged cheeses, cured meats and fresh fruit or as a dessert sauce for vanilla ice cream and strawberries. Makes a great marinade or a fabulous finish on your salmon.
